Mailing List

Sign up for email updates from Hot Corner Harbor any time there's a new post!

    Friday, November 20, 2026

    The 2026 Veterans Committee Ballot Has a Lot of Big New Names, and a Big Problem


    Feature photo by All-Pro Reels. Wikimedia Creative Commons License. 

    The MLB offseason is underway; awards have been handed out, free agent signings are underway, and most pertinent to Hot Corner Harbor, Hall of Fame elections have started!

    Well, sort of. Specifically, the Veterans Committee slate of candidates for the year had been announced; however, no voting will actually take place until just before the announcement on December 6th, when the committee meets to deliberate during the Winter Meetings. No word yet on who those voters will be, but we actually have quite the stacked ballot this year, which will be another one of the once-every-three-years non-player ballots. Our eight candidates this time around are:

    Sandy Alderson, Dusty Baker, Bruce Bochy, Joe Maddon, Lou Piniella, Brian Sabean, Ted Turner and Bill White

    the @baseballhall.org Contemporary Baseball Era Committee ballot for Managers/Executives/Umpires is out: Sandy Alderson, Dusty Baker, Bruce Bochy, Joe Maddon, Lou Piniella, Brian Sabean, Ted Turner and Bill White. To be voted upon and results announced on Dec. 6

    — Jay Jaffe (@jayjaffe.bsky.social) November 2, 2026 at 8:11 AM


    Like I said, I think this is a really strong group! Especially for a manager-and-executive ballot, which can sometimes hurt for star power. And in a really interesting twist (especially for the Veterans Committee), it’s actually chock full of first-time candidates! Usually, this bunch of sticks-in-the-mud just love cycling through the same eight or nine names, never admitting them but also never letting them fade away to give others a chance in the spotlight.



      Instead, only Lou Piniella and Bill White have been here before. And it makes sense that they’re back, given that they were the first and second runners-up to Jim Leyland back in 2023. Of course, if you’re familiar with my long-standing gripes against the VC, the alarm bells in the back of your head might be going off right now, but we’ll set those aside for a moment until we’ve gone over the names.


      Bruce Bochy seems like one of the easiest managerial votes imaginable. Who says no? The man has four World Series titles across two teams, including breaking both the Rangers’ franchise title drought and the Giants’ five-decade title drought following their move to San Francisco. Even his relative weak spot, the San Diego tenure, was pretty eventful; he brought the team one of their two pennants in team history, and remains their winningest manager ever even to this day. Technically, the man does have an overall losing record for his career (2252-2266, a .498 winning percentage but sixth all-time in total wins*), but like… c’mon. Who cares, he has four championships. Nobody is going to turn him away.

      *All stats from Baseball-Reference unless otherwise noted.

      Bochy is the rare manager who could push Dusty Baker to second banana in a ballot like this… and even then, I wouldn’t argue with anyone who flipped them in their order. His resume is impressive: a 2183-1862 record, eighth all time in wins, three-time Manager of the Year, took five different teams to the playoffs thirteen times in total (and all of five them as division winners at least once), won three pennants and helmed the Astros’ for their 2022 title. And somehow, that only just feels like scratching the surface here.

      Arguably, his days as a player were already Hall of Very Good-level (nearly 40 career WAR according to both B-R and Fangraphs, a couple of seasons making the All-Star team and finishing top-10 in MVP voting), plus in an incredible bit of extra credit, he co-invented the high five (or, at least, he performed the first recorded one). That feels insane, like there’s no way that the high five should have been invented in living memory or appeared so suddenly, but somehow Dusty Baker did it. His Wikipedia page has an entire section just devoted to unusual and historic moments that he was involved in, which is separate from the section devoted to all of his various personal accomplishments. The man really has done it all. I always say that the Hall should induct more people with multi-faceted careers from across different sides of the game, and Baker could be a poster child for that… but really, his managerial career by itself is already more than enough for induction.

      And while we’re on this kick of legends associated with the Giants, we’ve also got front office nominee Brian Sabean making his Hall ballot debut as well. As the General Manager of those Even-Year Champs, there’s a lot of overlap between his credentials and Bochy’s of course, but he was also there long enough to also add the 2002 Pennant to his resume. Three titles and another pennant seems like more than enough for a Hall resume, but if you somehow still weren’t convinced, Sabean’s big pre-Giants role was running the Yankees’ scouting and development in the late ‘80s and early ‘90s, meaning he was also responsible for getting them most of the core of their ‘90s dynasty. Yeah, I’m just not sure the voters can ignore a resume like that.

      And… that’s your 2026 Veterans Committee class! Great job everyone, we can call it here. See you next November, when we discuss the pre-1980 players eligible for–


      That may seem abrupt, but this was the major problem that I was alluding to earlier. These Veterans Committee ballots are all packed with qualified names, but they also turn around and put strict limits on how many players you can vote for, on top of each player needing to reach 75% of the vote. Lately, committee members have been limited to three ballot spots, and I haven’t seen anything changing that for this year.

      So the questions become: which of the three guys would you cut from your ballot? And even if you have some idiosyncratic reasoning to reach that conclusion, how many other voters can you see doing the same? And remember, you need eleven other voters to make the same choice as you to actually change the final induction results; if you all can’t agree on which fourth nominee you’re defecting for, it doesn’t matter much beyond denying votes to those top three candidates.

      Even if you got the entire committee to agree to spread out their votes as strategically as possible to maximize the worthy candidates getting into Cooperstown this year (something that I just can’t see happening), the upside is still limited. There are 16 ballots with 3 spots each, for a maximum of 48 votes; candidates need 12 votes to get over the line. You could, assuming no disagreements at all, get to one extra player. This just isn’t a realistic scenario.

      Which just sucks, there isn’t really another way to describe it. I think all five of these remaining guys have serious cases for enshrinement, but how can they even be heard when these three are going to be just dominating the conversation? It’s like back in the balloting for the 2014 ceremony, when Tony La Russa, Joe Torre, and Bobby Cox just wound up sucking up all of the oxygen. Those three were all unanimous, while eventual inductees Marvin Miller, Ted Simmons, and Dave Parker (plus deserving snub Tommy John, who passed away last August but still isn’t in) all had their cases unceremoniously punted down the line. And the voting thresholds have only gotten tighter in the years since.

      The consolation prize is that they’ll get another chance at induction three years from now, when the Non-Player Ballot cycles back around. But even that feels a little worthless; this is the same situation Lou Piniella and Bill White were in three years ago, and they just got blocked again! Piniella has now fallen one vote shy of induction in his last two ballot appearances (2023 and 2019), these guys clearly think he’s worthy, we’re just haggling over the specifics, but now he’s just going to fall even further behind and need try again because the VC couldn’t bother to throw him one more vote back in 2023 (when only Jim Leyland was selected).

      And there are real consequences here. Lou Piniella is 83; how many more “three years from now” do we want to bet on? And it’s not like he’s the only candidate where this is a very real consideration. Bill White will be 93 in January, while Sandy Alderson turns 79 this month and has already faced a cancer scare. “At least” Ted Turner made this a non-issue by passing away last May, except, you know, without even getting to make a ballot during his lifetime.

      I actually feel bad just kind of glossing over all of their credentials to this point, because like I’ve said, I think they’re all strong choices. And I actually wouldn’t mind any of them getting inducted, on the off-chance that actually happens! So just a quick refresher on what the elevator pitch for each one’s case would be:


      Lou Piniella: Seventeenth all-time in managerial wins, with a 1835-1713 record; won the 1990 World Series as manager of the Reds and led the Mariners during the 2001 116-win season; Three-time Manager of the Year; seven playoff appearances and 6 division titles with three different teams; plus, he had a decent 18-year career as a player on top of that; And as mentioned, he’s finished one vote away from induction two times in a row now

      Sandy Alderson: General Manager of the A’s during their late-’80s run, that saw them win three straight Pennants and the 1989 World Series; added another Pennant with the 2015 Mets; was a key figure in the growth and spread of advanced stats across the league, including both being an early adopter himself and serving as a mentor for others like Billy Beane

      Joe Maddon: Another three-time Manager of the Year; a career 1382-1216 record, despite a relatively late start to his managerial career; led the Tampa Bay Rays to their first success ever in franchise history, highlighted by their 2009 Pennant; somehow topped that underdog story in 2016 by leading the Cubs to their first World Series in over a century

      Bill White: A real all-around candidate; One of the stars in the early post-integration days, winning 7 Gold Gloves and making 8 All-Star teams while racking up over 30 career WAR; won the 1964 World Series with the Cardinals, and is in the team’s Hall of Fame; spoke out against the discrimination he and others faced, like the Jim Crow laws still in place at the time; after retiring, went on to over two-decades in sports broadcasting; also served as an executive in the game, acting as President of the National League for half a decade

      Ted Turner: Maybe the weakest candidate here, which is wild to think about; Turner was one of the most unique owners in baseball history, and definitely an interesting character; his work in bringing baseball to cable television were notable, getting the Braves a national fanbase through the use of his own networks and arguably setting the template for modern distribution of the game; his attempts at running the team directly were less successful (outside of being a notable figure in the early days of free agency), but once he got out of the way, the team became a dynasty in the ‘90, winning multiple pennants and their first World Series title in nearly 40 years (their first since moving to Atlanta)

      (I’m glad I took the time to write all those down; not just to make the point that they’re all worthy, but also to save myself some time three years from now when one or all of them are right back on the ballot.)


      Taken all together, that’s a pretty killer line-up! So… which one of Bochy, Baker, and Sabean are you dropping to add any of them? And how many Veterans Committee voters do you think you could peel off with your argument? The single best reasoning that I can think of is to prioritize the oldest members who are still alive to enjoy the honor, which I believe would be White, Piniella, and Alderson… but do you think you could convince voters to swap out all of the top three for them? And Baker is within a year of Alderson anyway, so drawing hard boundaries here feels unhelpful.

      Of course, maybe they take some kind of mixed approach here too. Maybe they decide to hold off on Sabean (the youngest candidate here) to get Piniella in sooner; that doesn’t strike me as particularly likely to happen, but it would at least line up with my suspicion that the VC voters tend to have a bias towards managerial candidates. Or maybe they’ll balk at Baker when there are so many single-World Series managers here, and pivot to Alderson or White (that one seems even less likely to me, but it’s easier for me to imagine a weird fluke like that than it is to think of a case where Bochy misses).

      Or, if the votes get spread too thin, we may see multiple candidates landing just short in the 8-to-11 vote range. That seems like the more likely problem to crop up. Theoretically, the Committee’s open discussion period should make it less likely, but we still regularly see guys just missing the 75% mark by a vote or two, so there are clearly some other factors at play here. Really, it could manifest here as something as simple as the voters being unable to agree upon who the actual third-best candidate is and splitting their votes evenly between two different guys. That’s really all it takes, and this scenario wouldn’t even require everyone agreeing to pass on one of the top three names and replacing them with the same alternative candidate.

      Look, there are technically a lot of minor variations in the way this could go. And maybe I’ll miss out on the exact results of the vote, but I feel pretty confident in the general outline of what will happen: there are a lot of worthy candidates and not a lot of actual ballot spaces for them, so the top candidates are probably going to absorb all of the votes and leave everyone else out in the cold.

      I’d still bet on Bochy, Baker, and Sabean getting in as the single most-likely outcome this year (Giants fans, maybe start looking for flights). And it will certainly be a very deserving class!

      But the other real takeaway here is that there are still many areas where the Hall needs to revise its voting systems, particularly in relation to the Veterans Committee, and there’s no area where that is more obvious than the non-player ballot. Constraining it to its own year in the VC’s current three-year cycle has always felt a little odd to me, and when we get ballots full of older names like this, it always makes me acutely aware of just how long three years can be. I don’t see a reason it couldn’t just run alongside a player ballot every other year or something.

      And perhaps even more importantly, there’s just no reason for the ballot limits to be as tight as they are. It already feels stupid to force a simple yes-or-no vote into a competition for ten slots on the BBWAA ballot, and the main result so far has been the ballot crunch of the 2010s that forced interesting candidates like Kenny Lofton, Johan Santana, Lance Berkman, and Jim Edmonds off the ballot early. The VC running an even tighter limit than that makes even less sense, given the higher bar for consideration and (theoretical) tighter control over the vote.

      But at least the players’ side of the equation has the justification of it being a backstop, a last resort for guys who have already had their cases heard and been voted on before. What justification is there on the non-player side, when this is the first and only way for them to be considered for Cooperstown? It remains a really silly decision, and it’s not even like a fix would be hard; I’ve thrown a few ideas, and any one of them by itself would probably help un-jam the process at least a little bit. And given the number of options they have here and the length of time it's been an issue, it’s kind of infuriating just how long the Hall of Fame has just sat on its hands and let these issues continue to plague the Veterans Committee process.

      New Hot Corner Harbor Email List, since Blogger broke the last one!

      The old subscription service doesn't seem to be working anymore, so if you'd like to receive emails when a new Hot Corner Harbor post goes up, sign up here!

        We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

        No comments:

        Post a Comment